Premier Colorado Property
Contemporary charcoal-clad home with cedar soffits, a sandstone entry, a deep tawny lawn and a bronze-leaved bur oak in morning light.

Fort Collins Restaurant Closings and Openings: Fall 2026

On Aug. 29, Courtney Wynter was at the fryer at Yum Yum Social, pulling out falafel on the restaurant's last day of service. "I am heartbroken, but I know change is inevitable," the executive chef told the Rocky Mountain Collegian.

Yum Yum Social had run for 35 years. Hakim's family opened it in 1991. Her mother did the cooking, and the restaurant got its name from the way customers reacted to her food. Less than two weeks later, Los Tarascos on South College announced it was closing after 31 years. In mid-September the Coloradoan ran a restaurant roundup under the headline "One restaurant era ends as another begins."

That headline fits, though the reasons behind these closings matter as much as the closings themselves. Fort Collins' best-known fall closures mostly happened on the owners' own schedule. Founders retired. An owner chose to rest. A lease ran out. In at least two of the vacated spaces, the next tenant has a personal connection to the business or building that came before. So for a regular, this season is less about losing places for good and more about figuring out where the people and the cooking went.

Why each one closed

Restaurant Location How long it ran Reason given What carries on
Yum Yum Social West Elizabeth Street 35 years, since 1991 Owner planned to rest before deciding her next step Sugar Plum café planned for the space, with the former owner advising
Los Tarascos 622 S. College Ave. 31 years Founding family retiring Sister restaurant La Buena Vida, plus a planned tequila line
Urban Egg 230 S. College Ave. More than a decade in Old Town Lease expiring, company chose not to renew Company said it would keep looking at Northern Colorado locations

None of these closings was blamed on a lack of customers. Los Tarascos announced its closing in a Sept. 9 social media post. The family called the decision "bittersweet," said the members who founded and ran the restaurant were retiring, and set Sept. 23 as the last day. Urban Egg named Aug. 30 as its final service at 230 S. College Ave. after more than a decade in Old Town. Its lease was expiring and the company chose not to renew; 9News reported that it said it would keep looking for opportunities elsewhere in Northern Colorado. At Yum Yum Social, Hakim said she planned to rest before deciding what to do next.

There is also a pattern in the addresses. Two of the three closings are on South College, at 230 and 622, and both owners announced their dates weeks ahead of time.

Where the cooking went

The Los Tarascos family is still in the restaurant business. In the closing announcement, the family pointed customers to its sister restaurant, La Buena Vida, and said it plans to launch a tequila line, with details to come. La Buena Vida's website lists its address as 901 East Harmony Road. That puts the family's remaining Fort Collins restaurant on the Harmony corridor, a long way from its old spot near Old Town. Anyone who used to walk or bike to 622 S. College now has a drive to make.

Yum Yum Social's space has a planned successor with a direct link to the old restaurant. Hunter Gottsch plans to open Sugar Plum there as an elevated café, and Hakim, the former owner, is advising her. As of the last reporting, Sugar Plum has no opening date and no published menu. The location and the former owner's involvement are the only confirmed details.

A family building, a new counter

The same kind of handoff happened on North College this summer. MilkShake Factory soft-opened July 24 at 150 N. College Ave. and scheduled a grand opening for Aug. 15. Zaki Kamandy, a local franchisee, owns and runs it. The shop sits in the same building where his parents opened a restaurant more than 45 years ago. It's a franchise brand, but the operator has family history in that storefront.

Trickster Bakery & Cafe is a second example of local owners moving into a vacated space. Co-owners Jenn Lewis and Shannon Morr opened Trickster on Aug. 10 at 1075 Pennock Place, in a building that used to be a Pizza Hut. A former chain location became an independent breakfast spot, which is the reverse of what usually happens to that kind of building.

The one the regulars kept open

Tandem Squared Rolled Ice Cream & Coffee Cafe almost became one of this summer's closings, and it shows what Fort Collins customers will do for a business they care about. The shop at 401 Mason Court is a social enterprise.

On July 29, the Colorado Department of Revenue shut the shop down over nearly $20,000 in back sales taxes. BizWest reported that the shop's 11 employees were paid ahead of some other bills. The state gave the owner 10 days to pay or close permanently. The owner started a GoFundMe on July 30, and the shop reopened Aug. 8. "Because of the incredible generosity of our community, we had enough money within a week," the owner said.

As of Sept. 23, the fundraiser had collected $9,715 from 95 donations. The shop often schedules two people during hours when another café might have one. The owner told BizWest that the shop is still applying for grants and taking donations to stay open.

The fall menu at Tandem includes apple-pie chai, peach-pie matcha, a s'more mocha, and a "Dubai Pistachio" rolled ice cream made with kadayif and a chocolate shell. The shop also has a downstairs meeting space that fits large study groups and a courtyard patio where customers bring their dogs in warmer weather.

What's new without a backstory

Not every new opening has a family connection. A few places opened this summer and fall with no link to an earlier tenant:

  • The Caldwell, inside The Buxton Hotel at 914 S. College Ave., was open by early July. The hotel owns the restaurant, and Chef Sol Shenker created the menu.
  • Firehouse Subs opened in June as the first new tenant at the renovated CSU Shops at College, 2427 and 2439 S. College Ave.
  • Copoco's Honey announced an Old Town retail space on Linden Street. It is the first announced tenant for three vacant storefronts there, and no opening date has been published.

The Caldwell is about three blocks south of the old Los Tarascos building, so South College picked up one sit-down restaurant this summer while losing two longtime ones.

The empty lot that got a dance floor

The site with the least settled future is North College Avenue's long-vacant Albertsons at 1636 N. College Ave. Plaza Unidas, a temporary events venue in the old grocery store's parking lot, was scheduled to hold its grand opening from 5:30 to 8 p.m. on Oct. 5, with salsa dancing and food trucks.

The Fort Collins Urban Renewal Authority owns the property. In June, its board approved $25,000 for operations and event coordination at the site. City planning materials from July say the property is in master planning, with a draft direction toward high-density mixed-use development and community-serving facilities. No final project or construction schedule has been set.

Plaza Unidas has not yet published a regular event calendar or said how long it will run. For now, it is a public, city-backed use of a parking lot while the longer plans get worked out.

If you want to keep eating at the places you're losing, here is the short version. The Los Tarascos family is still cooking at 901 E. Harmony Road. The former Yum Yum Social space on West Elizabeth is waiting for Sugar Plum, with Hakim advising. Tandem Squared on Mason Court is open, and its owner says it still needs customers to stay that way.

Every story above is about a handoff: a family retiring, an owner stepping back, a building moving to the next generation. Property goes through the same kinds of transitions, and the details matter just as much when it does. If you're handling a home after a retirement, an estate, or a big change in your family's plans, Premier Colorado Property can lay out the timeline and options in plain terms. Start a Conversation.

Work With Us

Every real estate decision comes with its own set of moving pieces. Whether you're buying, selling, investing, or simply exploring your options, our team is here to help you make sense of the puzzle. From Colorado Springs to the Wyoming Border. Mountains to the Plains. Reach out to start a conversation with your Colorado Real Estate Wealth Advisor.

Follow Me on Instagram